Scene: A dusky afternoon in the Vatican. The light from high windows slants across the unfinished vault of the Sistine Chapel. Scaffolding creaks faintly in the background. Michelangelo, spattered with pigment and fatigue, stands before Pope Julius II. The Pope, impatient yet curious, watches him from his elevated chair.
POPE JULIUS II
You are always so—difficult, Buonarroti. You resist honors, refuse coin, scorn praise. Why do you stand apart from your own glory like a man in mourning at his own feast?
MICHELANGELO
Because, Your Holiness, each of those things you name—honor, coin, praise—is a subtraction. A subtraction from the very thing I serve.
POPE
You serve me, Michelangelo. And God. Do not pretend your allegiance is solely to stone and plaster.
MICHELANGELO (steps closer, not kneeling, not bowing)
I serve that which is inside the stone. That which waits in the block and begs not to be disfigured by applause.
POPE (raising an eyebrow)
You speak in riddles again. Are you saying the laurel itself is an insult?
MICHELANGELO
Not always. But when a man begins to hunger for the laurel more than for the labor, he carves not for God, but for the crowd. And worse: he begins to carve for himself.
POPE
Is that pride or humility, I wonder?
MICHELANGELO
It is vigilance. For each time I feel the world affirm me—be it through a purse well-lined, or a look of envy from a lesser man—I feel something leave me. Some grain of necessity, some spark of struggle. And that, Your Holiness, is theft. Not from me. From the work. From Him.
POPE (leaning forward)
But we are all men. Even apostles craved bread and blessing. Would you live like a ghost?
MICHELANGELO
Perhaps I already do. I walk through Rome as though I belong to it, but I do not. I feel it every time I accept its comforts. Each affirmation I receive—from your court, from the bankers, from the silk-draped patrons who commission Venus and do not know her—weighs on me like a counterfeit soul.
POPE
And yet you build for us cathedrals. Paint for us heavens.
MICHELANGELO (quietly)
Because I must. But I must fight to keep that necessity pure. The system—this world of commissions and currencies—wants to make me grateful. It wants me to feel lucky. But art is not luck. Art is calling. And calling cannot be comfortable.
POPE
You speak as though virtue lives in suffering.
MICHELANGELO
No. But truth does.
(A silence. Dust motes drift. The Pope studies the ceiling, then Michelangelo.)
POPE
You are a dangerous man, Buonarroti. You speak treason with the tongue of a priest.
MICHELANGELO (half-smiling)
And you, Your Holiness, are a patron with the soul of a thief. You steal men from themselves—and in so doing, sometimes, you make them divine.
POPE (laughs, low and long)
Finish the ceiling. And remember—Rome only remembers saints once they’ve bled in the street.
MICHELANGELO (returning to the scaffold)
Then may I bleed not for Rome. But for the hand that shaped the clay.
[End Scene]